Comparison

Which ERP systems actually generate the Mushak forms

A form-by-form matrix across the systems sold in Bangladesh, with a source for every cell, five values instead of two ticks, and a twenty-minute demo test you can run on any vendor here. Including us.

Reviewed

The short answer

Of the systems sold into Bangladesh, only two have a written and checkable Mushak claim: ERPNext through a free partner-built marketplace application, and BizRP. The local VAT specialists state the widest coverage on their own pages and are the hardest to verify from outside. Tally, Odoo, Zoho Books and SAP Business One publish no Bangladesh Mushak capability at all.

No product in this comparison submits your return. Software produces the registers and computes the figures; a person signs in to the NBR portal and submits.

01

How to read this table before you read the table

Most comparison tables you will find on this subject are a grid of ticks with no source behind any of them. This one uses five values instead of two, because the honest answer to "does product X produce Mushak 6.3" is usually not yes or no.

What each value in the matrix means
ValueWhat it means
In the productProduced by the shipped product with no add-on.
Add-on appProduced by a separately installed application, not by the core product.
Vendor states itThe vendor's own materials say the product produces this. We have not run the software and are not vouching for it.
By handThe product holds the underlying data but does not lay it out in the statutory format. Somebody assembles it.
Not foundWe found nothing in the vendor's public materials claiming this form. That is not proof of absence, it is the absence of proof.
02

The matrix, form by form

Mushak form support across the ERP and VAT systems sold in Bangladesh
FormTallyPrimeERPNextOdooZoho BooksSAP Business OneBangladeshi VAT software vendorsBizRP
Mushak 6.1Purchase registerNot foundAdd-on appNot foundNot foundNot foundVendor states itIn the product
Mushak 6.2Sales registerNot foundAdd-on appNot foundNot foundNot foundVendor states itData held, not the form
Mushak 6.2.1Combined account bookNot foundAdd-on appNot foundNot foundNot foundVendor states itData held, not the form
Mushak 6.3VAT tax invoiceNot foundAdd-on appNot foundNot foundNot foundVendor states itIn the product
Mushak 6.6VDS certificateNot foundAdd-on appNot foundNot foundNot foundVendor states itNot produced
Mushak 9.1Monthly VAT returnNot foundBy handNot foundNot foundNot foundVendor states itIn the product

Checked . Every figure and quotation below was read from the vendor's own public pages on the date shown. Vendors change pricing, packaging and localisation without notice, so check the source link before you rely on anything here.

Three things are worth saying out loud about that grid. The international products are absent from this paperwork entirely, and none of them pretends otherwise. The only column with a written, checkable claim per form is the ERPNext one, because a Bangladeshi partner published an application listing that enumerates them. And the local VAT vendors, who are the specialists here, state the widest coverage of anyone and are the hardest to verify from outside.

03

Our own column, in full sentences

A one-word cell is not a claim anyone should buy on. Here is the same column written out, including the two rows where the answer is that we do not do it.

What BizRP does with each Mushak form, stated in full
FormWhat we actually do
Mushak 6.1BizRP keeps the input-VAT register from your supplier bills and purchase documents, one row per document with the input VAT, supplementary duty and other charges, and exports the period as CSV.
Mushak 6.2BizRP holds every line of sales data the register is built from, and maintains the Mushak 6.3 sales register over it. It does not lay that data out in the 6.2 book format.
Mushak 6.2.1BizRP holds both sides of the book as posted data, and maintains the 6.1 purchase register and the 6.3 sales register over it. It does not currently lay them out in the single 6.2.1 book format.
Mushak 6.3At the counter, BizRP allocates a gapless Mushak 6.3 number from an operator-configured series inside the transaction that completes the sale, so a sale cannot reach completed without one, a rollback returns the number rather than burning it, and a void keeps its number and is marked voided. Credit sales land in the same register carrying their sales invoice number from a separate sequence, not from that series, and cancelling a credit invoice does not currently mark its register rows voided. Every line of both channels lands with its taxable value, VAT rate and VAT amount, and the period exports as CSV in NBR column order. Two limits to know: supplementary duty is recorded as zero on every row today, so a business levying SD cannot rely on this register for it, and the buyer's BIN is captured at the counter but not yet on credit sales.
Mushak 6.6BizRP does not issue Mushak 6.6 certificates. Its withholding engine covers income tax deducted at source (TDS and AIT) on supplier payments, which is a different deduction under a different Act.
Mushak 9.1BizRP computes the return figure for a period: output VAT from the 6.3 register netted against creditable input VAT from the 6.1 register, resolving to either net VAT payable or a credit carried forward, with both source registers one click away for reconciliation. It does not file anything. A human submits on vat.gov.bd.
04

How to test any vendor's claim in twenty minutes

This is the section to use on us as well. Any vendor who cannot get through it in a live demo, on their own system, with you watching, has answered the question.

  1. Ask them to raise one sale and show you the Mushak 6.3 it produced. Not a sample PDF, not a screenshot in a deck. A sale, made in front of you, and the document that came out of it.
  2. Look at the number on that document. Ask where the series is configured, what happens to the number if the sale is cancelled halfway, and whether the register would show a gap. A gap in a statutory sequence is the first thing an officer looks for.
  3. Ask them to void that sale and show you the register again. The voided document should still be there, marked voided, keeping its number.
  4. Ask for the 6.1 purchase register for last month as an export, and open it. Check that the supplier BIN and the supplier's challan number are actually in it, because those are the columns your input-tax claim depends on.
  5. Ask them to show the Mushak 9.1 figure for a closed period and then click through from the output-tax number to the sales behind it. If the return figure cannot be traced back to documents, it is a typed number and you will be the one defending it.
  6. Ask what the product does at filing time. The correct answer from anyone is that a person signs in to the NBR portal and submits. Treat any answer implying automatic submission as a reason for a much harder follow-up question.
  7. Ask whether the VAT capability is in the product or in an add-on, and if it is an add-on, who supports it and what happens to your upgrade schedule.
05

What a vendor means by VAT ready

The phrase is doing a lot of work in this market and it usually means one of four different things. It is worth asking which.

Four things a vendor may mean by VAT ready
What they might meanWhat to ask
There is a tax field on the invoiceShow me the register that field rolls into.
There is a VAT reportIs it a report, or is it the Mushak form in its statutory layout with the columns in the right order?
It produces the Mushak documentsWhich ones, by number, and what happens to the numbering when a document is voided?
It handles the whole obligationNothing handles the whole obligation. Somebody signs in and submits. Ask them to say that out loud.

There is also a labelling question that comes up constantly, about what it means when a vendor calls itself listed or approved by the revenue authority. That is a real distinction with a real published register behind it, and it is worth understanding before you take any badge on any website at face value, ours included.

06

What each of these does better than we do

A comparison page written by a vendor is worth reading only if it contains this section. Here it is.

TallyPrime
TallyPrime is fast, works with no internet at all, publishes its Bangladesh price openly rather than hiding it behind a quotation, and a large pool of Bangladeshi accountants can already drive it on day one. That last point is a real switching cost and it is the strongest argument for staying.
ERPNext
ERPNext is genuinely free, genuinely open, and you can read every line of it. Its Bangladesh VAT app covers Mushak 6.6 VDS certificates and lays out the 6.2 and 6.2.1 books, neither of which BizRP does today. If you have Python capability in house and want to own your stack outright, ERPNext is the honest answer.
Odoo
Odoo's breadth is real, its app ecosystem is the largest in this comparison, and its One App Free tier genuinely gives unlimited users on a single app. If you need one narrow app for a large headcount, Odoo is cheaper than we are and it is not close.
Zoho Books
Zoho Books is a better pure accounting product than most things sold in this market, its bank feeds and its mobile apps are excellent, and if you invoice overseas clients in foreign currency it is a strong choice.
SAP Business One
SAP Business One is a serious system with real depth in manufacturing and multi-entity consolidation, and it comes with an auditor-familiar name on the box. For a group with foreign shareholders and a statutory audit, that name is worth money.
Bangladeshi VAT software vendors
A VAT-first local vendor will usually know more about your VAT circle, your commissionerate and your specific filing habits than any generalist, including us. If VAT filing is the whole of your problem, buying a VAT product rather than an ERP is a defensible decision.
07

Sources

Every cell above traces to one of these pages, read on the date shown. Where a vendor blocks automated reading of its site, the row says vendor states it rather than asserting anything we could not check.

Every source behind the competitor claims on this page, with the date it was read
ProductSourceRead on
TallyPrimeTally Solutions Bangladesh page
TallyPrimeTally Solutions Bangladesh buy page
ERPNextFrappe Cloud pricing
ERPNextBangladesh VAT Compliance app on the Frappe marketplace
ERPNextBangladesh VAT Compliance source, MIT licensed
OdooOdoo pricing
Zoho BooksZoho Books, editions and languages
SAP Business OneSAP Business One product page
Bangladeshi VAT software vendorsTroyee VAT Management Software
Bangladeshi VAT software vendorsMediasoft VAT accounting software
08

Questions people ask

Which ERP software generates Mushak 6.3 in Bangladesh?
Among the systems compared here, two have a written, checkable claim: ERPNext through the free Bangladesh VAT Compliance app published by Invento Software Limited, and BizRP, which allocates the Mushak 6.3 number inside the transaction that completes a counter sale, credit sales carrying their sales invoice number into the same register instead. The local VAT specialists state coverage of 6.3 and many more forms on their own pages. Tally, Odoo, Zoho Books and SAP Business One publish no Mushak claim for Bangladesh.
Does Odoo support Mushak forms?
Odoo publishes no Bangladesh localisation page and no Mushak content of its own. Bangladesh delivery is through partners, who build or buy the localisation, so the answer depends entirely on the partner rather than on Odoo.
Does SAP Business One handle Bangladesh VAT?
SAP publishes no Bangladesh localisation for Business One. Anything a Bangladeshi customer runs for Mushak is partner-built, and no Bangladeshi reseller publishes what that covers or what it costs.
Can Zoho Books file Bangladesh VAT?
No. Zoho Books lists its country editions explicitly, and Bangladesh is not among them. There is no Bangladesh edition and therefore no Bangladesh VAT handling, which is why searches for it return Zoho's help pages for other countries.
How do I check whether a vendor really produces Mushak 6.3?
Ask them to make a sale in front of you and show the document it produced, then ask them to void it and show the register again. The voided document should still be there, marked voided, keeping its number. Then ask when the number is allocated: at print time, or inside the transaction that completes the sale. Allocation at print time means two simultaneous prints can duplicate a number.
What does VAT ready mean when a vendor says it?
It can mean anything from a tax field on the invoice to a full set of statutory registers. Ask which Mushak forms by number, ask what the numbering does when a document is voided, and ask what happens at filing time. No software submits your return for you: a person signs in to the NBR portal and does it.
Does any software submit my VAT return to NBR automatically?
Not in this comparison, and you should treat any such claim with suspicion. Software produces the registers and the figures. A person signs in to vat.gov.bd and submits. A reader who believes their return went in automatically and discovers otherwise on the 16th has been harmed by the claim.

Get started

Stop running your business across five dashboards.

This page is a BizRP Builder layout

Everything between the navbar and the footer is rendered from JSON stored in our builder. Open it in your own workspace and edit your version.